Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: Mysterious Disappearing Paper Finally Reappears In Another Journal
Browsing all 28 articles
Browse latest View live

By: David Spector

Michael, There are quite a few individuals who, probably disillusioned either by their failure to reach enlightenment, which they thought was promised to them by the TM organization, or by changes that...

View Article



By: Michael H. Jackson

Let’s just stick to the facts David. A- I never said a word about the “evils of transcending” those are your words and they are an incorrect assumption. B – I still use my TM mantra sometimes and have...

View Article

By: Bjarne Ulrich Hansen

It seems there are serious points of justified critique to the article published by Dr. Robert Scheneider et al in Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality & Outcome. 1) Dr Schneider seem to be in...

View Article

By: tammy harshaw

You express a lot of negative opinions, “Michael H Jackson,” but there is no evidence or any real-world truths for your condemnations of TM and the foundation that teaches it. For example, “the many...

View Article

By: tammy harshaw

This is a compelling and important study. It has gone through far more scrutiny and peer-review analysis than studies usually do, and no design flaws were identified. There is also a strong precedence...

View Article


By: tammy harshaw

The accusations of manipulating data are completely unfounded, as far as I can see. Where is there any evidence at all to support that? It’s just negative speculation. The “$20M” from the NIH is not a...

View Article

By: tammy harshaw

To address the qualms and insinuations here: “The paper reports on 52 primary endpoint events (the composite of death, MI, or stroke). Of these, 20 events occurred in the TM group and 32 in the HE...

View Article

By: Larry Husten

Tammy, thank you for carefully reading this and pointing out several errors. I have corrected the story and added an update notice. Here is my response to your points: 1. You are correct that I wrongly...

View Article


By: Bill Kossler

Dear David, I have read with interest the exchange between you and a friend of mine, Michael H. Jackson, and felt I just had to comment – my first on any kind of blog whatsoever. I’ve also been...

View Article


By: Michael H. Jackson

Tammy some of what I have written are my opinions and some are facts. If by empirical data you mean there are no scientific studies on the people who have problems from long term TM practice,...

View Article

By: Michael H. Jackson

Having made several posts here I would like to make one more for clarification. I am in no way shape or form a scientist and can hardly make heads or tails of scientific data presented in such papers...

View Article

By: Investigator Defends Controversial Transcendental Meditation Paper «...

[...] Note: Here is a response by Dr. Robert Schneider to my story last week about his controversial paper on Transcendental Meditation that appeared in Circulation: [...]

View Article

By: Emily

Thank you, Larry, for following this story. I really don’t see why my tax dollars should go to studying a religion for the purposes of medicine. The real problem with all of these studies is that they...

View Article


By: Chrissy

There is so much wrong with David Spector’s posts that it’s hard to know where to begin. One thing I have learned about TM teachers is that they are BIG talkers. It’s like if they just keep spewing and...

View Article

By: Chrissy

One should always be skeptical of any medical or other practice that finds “all-positive” results. I am a brain scientist myself (Ivy-league educated and highly regarded). There is nothing under the...

View Article


By: Chrissy

Another key to identifying scientific cover-up is Tammy’s statement that “no design flaws were identified.” As a brain scientist for the past 20 years, I can attest to the fact that the perfect study...

View Article

By: Chrissy

I love this sentence from Bill Kossler: “There seems to be an inverse relationship between a person’s position in the movemetn and their general ability to relate in a normal, human way.” It made me...

View Article


By: Chrissy

I know many TM insiders, and Michael H. Jackson speaks the truth. I found it really humorous recently when some TM insiders were going on and on about how bogus Scientology is and how silly of anyone...

View Article

By: Chrissy

Yes, pyramid scheme, exactly!

View Article

By: Yet Another Look At The Transcendental Meditation Paper « CardioBrief

[...] the comments left by Michael Jackson and Chrissy on my earlier post to learn more about the dangers of TM. Or do your own research on the [...]

View Article
Browsing all 28 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images